2024
See BYD Atto 3 for saleBYD Atto 3
From QAR 148,500
BYD Atto 3 vs Tesla Model Y: Which Should You Buy in Qatar?
A complete comparison of the BYD Atto 3 VS Tesla Model Y — specs, prices, pros and cons, and live used listings across Qatar.
2024
See Tesla Model Y for saleTesla Model Y
From QAR 184,990
BYD Atto 3 VS Tesla Model Y: the verdict
The Tesla Model Y emerges as the superior choice for buyers prioritizing performance, expansive cargo capacity, and longer range. However, the BYD Atto 3 presents a highly attractive alternative for the budget-conscious shopper in Qatar, offering a compelling electric SUV experience at a significantly lower entry price.
| #1 BYD Atto 3#1 | #2 Tesla Model Y#2 | |
|---|---|---|
| Price Comparison | ||
| Starting at | 148,500 QAR | 184,990 – 229,000 QAR |
| Engine & Power | ||
| Horsepower (bhp) | 201 hp | 204 – 534 hp |
| Torque (Nm) | 310 Nm | 350 – 527 Nm |
| Acceleration 0-100 Km/h (sec) | 7.3 s | 3.7 – 6.9 s |
| Top Speed (Km/h) | 160 km/h | 217 – 250 km/h |
| Gears | 1 | 1 |
| Transmission | Automatic | Automatic |
| Drive Type | Front Wheel Drive | All Wheel Drive / Rear Wheel Drive |
| Fuel Type | Electric | Electric |
| Battery Size | 60.5 kWh | 50 – 80.5 kWh |
| Battery Range (km) | 420 km | 455 – 533 km |
| Measurements | ||
| L×W×H | 4.5 m × 1.9 m × 1.6 m | 4.8 m × 1.9 m × 1.6 m |
| Wheelbase (meters) | 2.7 m | 2.9 m |
| Curb Weight (kg) | 1,750 kg | 1,909 – 1,995 kg |
| Trunk Capacity (liters) | 440 L | 854 L |
| Overview | ||
| Body Style | SUV Crossover | SUV Crossover |
| Seating Capacity | 5 seats | 5 / 7 seats |
| Doors | 4 doors | 5 doors |
| Features | ||
| Key features | 360-Degree Camera360-Degree CameraAcoustic HoodActive SteeringAir ConditioningAirbagsAlloy PedalsAluminum WheelsAnti theft alarmAnti-theft Wheel BoltsAppsAuto Door LockAuto Handbrake Release FunctionAutomatic ACBA (Brake Assist)Blind Spot WarningBluetoothBody Colored GrilleCentral LockingChrome Door HandlesChrome Exhaust PipesClimate ControlCollision DetectionCrosswind AssistCupholdersDaytime Running LightsDoor ReflectorsDynamic Stability ControlEBD (Electronic Brakeforce Distribution)Electric Door MirrorsFire ExtinguisherFog Lamp - Front and RearFoldable Rear SeatsGas Shock AbsorberHDMIHill AssistImmobilizerKeyless EntryLeather SeatsLED Fog LightsLED HeadlightsLED TaillightsLegroomMudguardMulti-Information DisplayMulti-Information Display SizeNight VisionNumber of SpeakersOBD (On-board Diagnostics)Off-Road DampersPanoramic Glass RoofParking SensorsPedestrian airbagPower SteeringPower TailgatePower Windows - Front and RearPush Button StartRacing Or Bucket SeatsRadioRear AC VentsRear Audio ControlsRear CameraRear Lcd screensSeat Adjustment - AutomaticSpeed Sensitive Windshield WipersSpoilerSurround CameraTiptronic GearsTouchscreen SizeTPMS (Tire Pressure Monitoring System)Tyre Pressure Monitoring DisplayUrethane Steering WheelUSB PortWheel SizeWheels - AlloyWinchWireless HeadphonesWood Trim | 360-Degree Camera360-Degree CameraABS (Anti-lock Brake System)Acoustic HoodActive HeadrestsActive SteeringActive Understeer Control (AUC)Air ConditioningAirbagsAlloy PedalsAluminum WheelsAnti theft alarmAnti-theft Wheel BoltsAppsAuto Door LockBlind Spot WarningBluetoothBody Colored GrilleBumper Side StepCenter Arm RestCentral LockingChrome Door HandlesChrome Exhaust PipesCigar LighterClimate ControlCollision DetectionCrosswind AssistCruise ControlDaytime Running LightsDoor Edge ProtectorDoor ReflectorsEBD (Electronic Brakeforce Distribution)Electric Door MirrorsElectric Opening and Closing of Luggage DoorElectric SunroofFire ExtinguisherFirst Aid KitFog Lamp - Front and RearFog LightsFoldable Rear SeatsFoldable Rear Seats with 60:40 SplitFront CameraGas Shock AbsorberGlove Box CoolingHDMIHeated SeatsHeel-and-ToeHID HeadlightsImmobilizerInfotainment ScreenISOFIX Child Seat AnchorsKeyless EntryKnee AirbagLeather SeatsLeather Steering WheelLED Fog LightsLED HeadlightsLED TaillightsLegroomMoonroofMoving Object Detection SystemMudguardMulti-Information DisplayMulti-Information Display SizeNight VisionNumber of SpeakersOBD (On-board Diagnostics)Off Road KItOff-Road DampersPanoramic Glass RoofParking SensorsPedestrian airbagPerformance TyresPower LocksPower MirrorsPower OutletsPower SeatsPower SteeringPower TailgatePower WindowsPower Windows - Front and RearPush Button StartRacing Or Bucket SeatsRadioRear Audio ControlsRear CameraRear Lcd screensRemote StartRemote Windows DownRun Flat TiresSoft-closing DoorsSpare WheelSpeed LimiterSpeed Sensitive Windshield WipersSpoilerSports Exhaust SystemSteering Tilt AdjustmentTemperature DisplayTiptronic GearsToolkitTouchscreenTPMS (Tire Pressure Monitoring System)Traction ControlTyre Pressure Monitoring DisplayTyre Repair KitUSB PortVariable Cylinder Management (VCM)Wheel SizeWheels - AlloyWinchWind BlockerWireless HeadphonesWood Trim |
Which one should you buy?
1
Best Value EV
The BYD Atto 3 offers an excellent electric package at a starting price of 148,500 QAR, making it a more accessible entry point into the EV SUV segment compared to the Model Y.
2
Best for Performance
For thrill-seekers, the Tesla Model Y is the undisputed winner, boasting up to 534 hp and an exhilarating 0-100 km/h acceleration in as little as 3.7 seconds.
3
Best for Families & Space
The Tesla Model Y shines for families needing ample room, featuring a generous 854 L trunk and an optional 7-seat configuration, far exceeding the Atto 3's 440 L and 5-seat layout.
4
Best for Longer Trips
With a maximum driving range of up to 533 km, the Tesla Model Y offers greater peace of mind for extended journeys compared to the BYD Atto 3's 420 km range.
Pros & cons
BYD Atto 3
Pros
- More affordable starting price (148,500 QAR)
- Competitive standard range for its class (420 km)
- Sufficient power for daily driving (201 hp)
- Distinctive and modern interior design
Cons
- Lower maximum driving range (420 km vs 533 km)
- Smaller trunk capacity (440 L vs 854 L)
- No 7-seat option
- Less powerful engine (201 hp vs up to 534 hp)
- Only Front-Wheel Drive
Tesla Model Y
Pros
- Superior maximum power output (up to 534 hp)
- Faster acceleration (as quick as 3.7s)
- Significantly larger trunk space (854 L)
- Optional 7-seat configuration
- Longer maximum driving range (up to 533 km)
- Available All-Wheel Drive
Cons
- Higher starting price (from 184,990 QAR)
- Longer wheelbase might impact city maneuverability for some
- Heavier kerb weight (1,909 kg vs 1,750 kg)
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the BYD Atto 3 or Tesla Model Y better for families in Qatar?
The Tesla Model Y is generally better for families due to its significantly larger 854 L trunk capacity and the availability of an optional 7-seat configuration, offering more versatility for passengers and cargo. The BYD Atto 3, while a capable 5-seater, has a smaller 440 L trunk. For growing families or those needing extra space, the Model Y is the clear winner.
Which electric SUV offers better performance, the BYD Atto 3 or Tesla Model Y?
The Tesla Model Y offers superior performance, especially in its higher trims, with up to 534 hp and an acceleration time of just 3.7 seconds. The BYD Atto 3 provides a respectable 201 hp and 7.3 seconds 0-100 km/h, which is adequate for most daily driving, but it cannot match the raw power and speed of the Model Y. For performance enthusiasts, the Model Y is the better choice.
What is the price difference between the BYD Atto 3 and Tesla Model Y in Qatar?
The BYD Atto 3 has a starting price of 148,500 QAR, making it a more budget-friendly option. The Tesla Model Y starts from 184,990 QAR and can go up to 229,000 QAR for higher trims. This significant price difference makes the Atto 3 an attractive choice for buyers looking for an accessible entry into the EV SUV segment without compromising too much on features.
Which car has a longer driving range, the BYD Atto 3 or Tesla Model Y?
The Tesla Model Y offers a longer maximum driving range, capable of up to 533 km on a single charge depending on the trim. The BYD Atto 3 provides a solid 420 km range. For drivers who frequently undertake longer journeys or prefer fewer charging stops, the Model Y's extended range provides a practical advantage.
Is the BYD Atto 3 or Tesla Model Y better for cargo space?
The Tesla Model Y is significantly better for cargo space, boasting a generous 854 liters of trunk capacity. In contrast, the BYD Atto 3 offers 440 liters. If maximizing cargo volume for luggage, groceries, or sports equipment is a priority, the Model Y clearly outperforms the Atto 3.
